Home
Up

TV

Current thinking:

    For large screen, go with DLP

    For up to mid size, go with LCD (larger sizes get super expensive and the blacks are not black enough).

LCD Plasma (no) DLP Projection
Retains color sharpness Colors fade slowly and can't be recharged. Light source is replaceable to refresh any fade  
Great picture 45% either side of centerline. Noisy    
Light source is replaceable Produces heat    
16:9 units are expensive Subject to image burn-in    
  Power hungry    

   

Compare LCD TV vs Plasma TV Vs DLP TV Big Screen tv's  (VERY GOOD REFERENCE)

 

 

The Difference Between HDTV, EDTV, and SDTV

Plasma vs LCD TV - Plasma TV Buying Guide

PCWorld.com - How to Buy a Rear-Projection TV

Important: Viewing Angle

Because of the nature of their screens, rear-projection TV images tend to lose brightness as you move away from directly in front of them, especially on CRT-based sets. The effect is usually more pronounced vertically than horizontally, but since people tend to watch from the same height all the time, the vertical fade is less important. How much the horizontal viewing angle matters depends on how your seating area is set up, but the closer a set gets to a 180-degree acceptable viewing angle, the better. And though a viewing-angle spec can be a handy rough guide, there is no substitute for checking this out with your own eyes.

PCWorld.com - Rear-Projection TVs Step Up

PCWorld.com - How to Buy a Flat-Screen TV

PCWorld.com - Living Large With Good Shows From Plasma and Rear-Protection DLP TVs

However, the size of these LCD sets will probably top out in the mid-40-inch range due to the economics of the flat-panel manufacturing business. Above 46 inches, plasma and rear-projection technologies will be battling for market share.

PCWorld.com - Flat-Panel TVs Time to Go Skinny

A Clear Winner

As it turns out, the answer may be a lot simpler than most people think.

Plasma screens initially seem to be the better deal because they offer the best bang for the buck on the showroom floor. Today, $3000 will get you either a 30-inch LCD or a much larger 42-inch plasma TV. But a number of issues with plasma technology make the screens a poor fit for consumers, warns Jon Peddie, principal of Jon Peddie Research in Tiburon, California.

"They look great when they're new. It's a fantastic experience when you see one," Peddie says. But he warns: "The screen is hot, expensive, and noisy. It burns in; it wears out. For all those reasons, I don't think plasma is an appropriate solution for the home."

DLP TV Buying Guide, Read DLP TV Reviews, Research Samsung, Toshiba and Panasonic DLP TV sets

DLP Television DLP TV vs LCD TV - Which is best

VIEWING ANGLE

Manufacturers claim viewing angles of 160-170° for both LCD and DLP displays. The viewable picture at these extreme angles is quite impressive for both technologies. The picture on the LCD displays remained consistent throughout all viewing angles. This was not the case with the DLP TVs. Viewing a DLP set from various angles will impact the overall color accuracy of the image. There is a considerable shift in the tints when changing vertical positions. You will notice this if you shift positions (i.e., stand up or sit down) while watching your DLP unit.

Advantage: LCD. If having a sizeable "sweet spot" for optimal viewing pleasure is a must, then an LCD television is your best bet.
 

Advantage: LCD, with the following caveat: The LCD TVs will be brighter and have a distinct color accuracy advantage during the first few years of their lives (each sets has about a 70,000-hour lifespan). An LCD panel will slowly decay with time, as will its backlight(s). This decay will result in colors that slowly shift (towards more red or blue) over time. DLP technology, on the other hand, may not be quite as accurate, but the colors will not shift over the course its lifespan. The lamps can also be replaced in DLP units (sometimes easily), which should return them to their original brightness levels.


What Is The Estimated Life-Span of a DLP Television?
A DLP-based HDTV set should last indefinitely because the digital micromirror device behind it is very reliable. There is no maintenance or alignment required for DLP based sets as they age. The only consumer replaceable component is the DLP light source (lamp) which will last for 8,000 hours and costs around $250 to replace. The micro-mirrors used in DLP are not subject to degradation due to heat, humidity, vibration or "burn-in".

What size DLP TV screen should I purchase?
The optimal screen size to choose is a function of your viewing distance from the screen - usually constrained by the size of your living room. The "rule of thumb" formula to determine screen size is:

bulletdivide the diagonal screen measurement in half to get an approximate screen height for 16:9 aspect ratio HDTVs
bulletmultiply the height by 3.2 to determine optimal viewing distance for 1080i content, or multiply by 4.8 to get the optimal distance for 720p content.
For example, take a 720p Samsung 43" diagonal HLN4365W, the screen height is roughly 21 inches, which when multiplied by 4.8 yields 100.8 inches, or 8.4 feet as an optimal viewing distance. At a typical living room distance of 10 feet, this screen would be too small to see fine detail on the screen. Backing out the optimal screen size, 10ft is 120 inches, and dividing by 4.8, that would require a 25 inch vertical height, or approximately a 50 inch diagonal HDTV for optimal perception of the 720p screen resolution from 10ft.

 

LCD TV Buying Guide Read LCD TV Reviews, LCD Television and Flat Screen TV Buying Advice

 

 

Last updated 08/30/2007